Add a Comment Comments 2

Strengths:

Original project and good sounds

Simple to understand and operate

Weaknesses

Lack of variation

Plain colors

Lack of in-depth interactivity

Opportunities

With additional work, this could be used as a desktop screensaver or web-based flash game for children. Nice simple design make is easy to understand and utilize. However further work is needed in order to take it further.

Strengths:
The image of the fish invite curiosity. Demonstrates capability to trigger sounds with rollovers.

Weaknesses:
There are only four sounds triggered by 1 kind of rollover interaction. There is no graphic interaction or cues about where the sounds are. It does not hold interest for more than a few moments and does not invite a second visit to find out more.

Opportunities:
The crits of your draft were very positive about the barcode image as an interesting interface and metaphor. it also suggests more creative interaction metaphors, such as running the mouse across the bars.

Overall a very limited effort that merely deonstrates a basic capability to trigger sounds, and does not meet the brief in terms of showing different kinds of interactivity and engaging the user
The crits on your draft were very positive about the visual 'bar code/piano key' metaphor. The change to fish in the final version is a radical response. However the same four soundfiles are used.